From Empirical Bayes to Full Bayes: Methods for Analyzubg Traffic Safey Data, October 25, 2004

(2004) From Empirical Bayes to Full Bayes: Methods for Analyzubg Traffic Safey Data, October 25, 2004. Transportation, Department of

[img]
Preview
PDF
eb_fb_comparison_whitepaper_october2004.pdf

Download (230kB)

Abstract

Traffic safety engineers are among the early adopters of Bayesian statistical tools for analyzing crash data. As in many other areas of application, empirical Bayes methods were their first choice, perhaps because they represent an intuitively appealing, yet relatively easy to implement alternative to purely classical approaches. With the enormous progress in numerical methods made in recent years and with the availability of free, easy to use software that permits implementing a fully Bayesian approach, however, there is now ample justification to progress towards fully Bayesian analyses of crash data. The fully Bayesian approach, in particular as implemented via multi-level hierarchical models, has many advantages over the empirical Bayes approach. In a full Bayesian analysis, prior information and all available data are seamlessly integrated into posterior distributions on which practitioners can base their inferences. All uncertainties are thus accounted for in the analyses and there is no need to pre-process data to obtain Safety Performance Functions and other such prior estimates of the effect of covariates on the outcome of interest. In this light, fully Bayesian methods may well be less costly to implement and may result in safety estimates with more realistic standard errors. In this manuscript, we present the full Bayesian approach to analyzing traffic safety data and focus on highlighting the differences between the empirical Bayes and the full Bayes approaches. We use an illustrative example to discuss a step-by-step Bayesian analysis of the data and to show some of the types of inferences that are possible within the full Bayesian framework.

Item Type: Departmental Report
Keywords: Transportation, Traffice Safety, Analyzing Crash Data
Subjects: Transportation > Research
Transportation > Traffic safety
Transportation > Roads and highways
Transportation > Design and Construction
Transportation
ID Code: 13274
Deposited By: Margaret Barr
Deposited On: 02 Jul 2012 16:07
Last Modified: 02 Jul 2012 16:07
URI: http://publications.iowa.gov/id/eprint/13274

Actions (login required)

View Item View Item