MICHAEL RICHARDSON, Complainant,
VS.
AMERICAN CAN COMPANY, DES MOINES, IOWA and GREENWICH, CT., Respondent.
FINDINGS OF FACT
1. The Complainant, Michael
Richardson, timely filed verified complaint CP#09-83-10966 on
September 19, 1983, charging American Can Company of Des Moines,
Iowa and Greenwich, Connecticut, with discrimination in employment
on the basis of race.
2. The complaint was amended
on July 17, 1984, to change the date of termination from August
22 to August 23.
3. Investigation was completed
on November 19, 1985, probable cause was found on November 22,
1985, conciliation attempted but failed and Notice of Hearing
was issued on November 4, 1986.
4. Richardson started work
for American Can Company in Des Moines on July 26, 1983 as a quality
control tester. Richardson is a Black person and was the only
Black person in the quality control department. His immediate
supervisor was Nancy Favilia and his department head was Kevin
Cook. Neither appeared as witness although interviews with each
one by the investigator were introduced as evidence. (See Complainant's
Exhibits 31 and 32).
5. Richardson was placed
on probation for 30 days as is a union requirement at ACC. A performance
report was done regularly by his immediate supervisor.
6. Richardson was a college
graduate with a major in chemistry. He had worked in quality control
at Firestone for several years prior to his job with ACC.
7. Richardson's job with
ACC was working with saran, plastic bags to measure materials
to make sure they would not burst under pressure. He used the
microscope and two machines--the Ohmart and the Winzen.
8. Richardson's first report
dated 8-1-83, was good. His second report, dated 8-12-83, indicated
he had a lack of confidence and was having some problems with
the microscope and Winzen. His third report, dated 8-16-83, indicated
a lack of progress, a need for improvement in attitude toward
work, problems with the Winzen after a review of the procedure,
and comments by coworkers and supervisors that he is "arrogant."
The report indicates that these matters were discussed with Richardson
and that if there was no improvement, he would be "let go".
Richardson admitted that the reports reflected the termination
discussion except for the specific Winzen data. (see complainant's
Exhibits 27, 28, 29, 30).
9. On 8-23-83, Richardson
was terminated because of "performance/cooperation."
He was stunned because he thought he had turned things around.
10. On 8-24-83, ACC hired
Kevin Mersch, a white person, to replace Complainant.
11. For the 28 days of work
with ACC, Complainant received $1465.04. He also received unemployment.
(See Complainant's Exhibit 35). He was hired by AVCO on November
7, 1983 where he earned the following: 1983, $2024.43; 1984, $15,455.07;
1985, $15,546.72; 1986, $16,583.04; 1987, $5,395.33. He also worked
part- time at Sears where he earned $1526.07 in 1983.
12. Complainant admits that
no one made racially derogatory remarks to him at ACC nor was
race mentioned in the termination meeting.
13. The Des Moines plant
of ACC employed approximately 320 people. The company is an industrial
supplier for flexible packaging. The saran department is one of
several departments.
14. A college degree is not a requirement for the quality control tester positions.