DIGEST OF DECISIONS

OF THE IOWA CIVIL RIGHTS COMMISSION,

THE IOWA DISTRICT COURTS

AND THE IOWA APPELLATE COURTS

 


AREA OF JURISDICTION (Agency Contested Case Decisions only)

Employment

Ann M. Redies

Hoa Thi Blood

Robert E. Swanson

Stephanie Juehring

Michael Biggles (Lovelady)

Rachel Helkenn

Public Accommodation

Diane Humburd

Diane Humburd (Supplemental Decision)

 


BASIS OF COMPLAINT (Agency Contested Case Decisions only).

Aiding and Abetting (includes retaliation)

Robert E. Swanson

Age

Robert E. Swanson

Rachel Helkenn

Disability

Michael Biggles (Lovelady)

National Origin

Hoa Thi Blood

Race

Diane Humburd

Diane Humburd (Supplemental Decision)

Sex

Ann M. Redies

Hoa Thi Blood

Stephanie Juehring



INCIDENTS OF ALLEGED DISCRIMINATION (Agency Contested Case Decisions only)

Constructive Discharge

Ann M. Redies

Discriminatory Advertising

Robert E. Swanson

Discharge

Rachel Helkenn

Equal Pay

Ann M. Redies

Failure to Hire/Promote

Ann M. Redies

Hoa Thi Blood

Robert E. Swanson

Michael Biggles (Lovelady)

Failure to Provide Child Care Services

Diane Humburd

Termination of Employment

Rachel Helkenn


ADMINISTRATIVE LAW

Administrative Rules

Hollinrake v. Law Enforcement Academy

Annear v. State

Contested Case

Diane Humburd

Dismissal of Contested Case

Stephanie Juehring

Due Process

Hollinrake v. Law Enforcement Academy

Keokuk Steel Casting v. Iowa Civil Rights Commission (District Court)

Official Notice

Diane Humburd

Hollinrake v. Law Enforcement Academy

Other Agency Action

Vislisel v. Iowa Civil Rights Commission



DEFENSES (BOTH ACTUAL AND SPURIOUS)

Appeasement of the Desires of a Mentally III Person

Diane Humburd

Business Necessity

Michael Biggles (Lovelady)

Hy-Vee Food Stores, Inc. v. Iowa Civil Rights Commission

Soloman v. State

Prudential Insurance Company v. Iowa Civil Rights Commission (District Court)

Customer Preference

Diane Humburd

Conduct Not "Unwelcome" in Harassment Cases

Lynch v. City of Des Moines

Failure to Mitigate Damages

Diane Humburd

Robert E. Swanson

Michael Biggles (Lovelady)

Rachel Helkenn

Best Western Holiday Motor Lodge v. Iowa Civil Rights Commission (District Court)

United Parcel Service v. Iowa Civil Rights Commission (District Court)

Prudential Insurance Company v. Iowa Civil Rights Commission (District Court)

Economic Savings

Hulme v. Barrett

Inadequate Notice

Robert E. Swanson

Inappropriate Manner of Expressing Opposition

Vislisel v. Iowa Civil Rights Commission

Individualized Assessment of Disability

Michael Biggles (Lovelady)

Smith v. ADM Feed Corporation

Lack of Jurisdiction

Diane Humburd (Subject matter jurisdiction)

Christie v. Rolscreen (Jurisdiction of the particular case).

Lynch v. City of Des Moines (Jurisdiction of the particular case).

Prudential Insurance Company v. Iowa Civil Rights Commission (District Court) (subject matter jurisdiction)

Legitimate Factors in a Mixed Motives Case

Ann M. Redies

Hulme v. Barrett

Hy-Vee Food Stores, Inc. v. Iowa Civil Rights Commission

Landals v. Rolfes

Legitimate Non-Discriminatory Reasons

Ann M. Redies

Rachel Helkenn

Hulme v. Barrett

Hy-Vee Food Stores, Inc. v. Iowa Civil Rights Commission

Members of Both Sexes Subjected to Obscene Language

Lynch v. City of Des Moines

Mental Illness

Diane Humburd

Nature of the Occupation Defense

Michael Biggles (Lovelady)

Smith v. ADM Feed Corporation

Soloman v. State

Preference of Family Members

Diane Humburd

Qualifications

Ann M. Redies

Robert E. Swanson

Reasonable Accommodation Not Possible

Smith v. ADM Feed Corporation

Soloman v. State

Henkel Corporation v. Iowa Civil Rights Commission (District Court).

Reasonable Probability of Substantial Harm

Michael Biggles (Lovelady)

Remedial Action (Defense to Harassment Charges)

Lynch v. City of Des Moines

Statute of Limitations

Hoa Thi Blood

Robert E. Swanson

Hy-Vee Food Stores, Inc. v. Iowa Civil Rights Commission

Annear v. State

Lynch v. City of Des Moines

J & J Motors v. Iowa Civil Rights Commission (District Court)

Hy-Vee Food Stores, Inc. v. Iowa Civil Rights Commission (District Court)

Statutory Exceptions

Diane Humburd

Term, Condition or Privilege of Employment Not Affected

Lynch v. City of Des Moines

Unconstitutionally Vague Statute

Lynch v. City of Des Moines

Undue Hardship

Smith v. ADM Feed Corporation

Soloman v. State

 

DEFINITIONS

Adjudicative Facts

Hollinrake v. Law Enforcement Academy

Alcoholism

Brown v. Clark-Peterson Company, Inc. (District Court)

"Because of" Sex

Ann M. Redies

Burden of Persuasion

Diane Humburd

Ann M. Redies

Robert E. Swanson

Michael Biggles (Lovelady)

Rachel Helkenn

Burden of Production

Diane Humburd

Ann M. Redies

Robert E. Swanson

Michael Biggles (Lovelady)

Rachel Helkenn

Business Necessity

Michael Biggles (Lovelady)

Consequential Damages

Diane Humburd

Constructive Discharge

Ann M. Redies

Contested Case

Diane Humburd

Continuing Violation

Hoa Thi Blood

Hy-Vee Food Stores, Inc. v. Iowa Civil Rights Commission

Lynch v. City of Des Moines

Perkins v. International Union of Operating Engineers

J & J Motors v. Iowa Civil Rights Commission (District Court)

Hy-Vee Food Stores, Inc. v. Iowa Civil Rights Commission (District Court)

Default

Diane Humburd

De Minimus Standard

Smith v. ADM Feed Corporation

Soloman v. State

Disability

Michael Biggles (Lovelady)

Fogel v. Trustees of Iowa Colleges

Hollinrake v. Law Enforcement Academy

Annear v. State

Soloman v. State

Henkel Corporation v. Iowa Civil Rights Commission (District Court)

Disparate Impact

Hy-Vee Food Stores, Inc. v. Iowa Civil Rights Commission

Prudential Insurance Company v. Iowa Civil Rights Commission (District Court)

Disparate Treatment

Hy-Vee Food Stores, Inc. v. Iowa Civil Rights Commission

Equal Responsibility (Equal Pay Cases)

Ann M. Redies

Impairment

Michael Biggles (Lovelady)

Hollinrake v. Law Enforcement Academy

Annear v. State

Soloman v. State

Henkel Corporation v. Iowa Civil Rights Commission (District Court)

Judicial Notice

Diane Humburd

Jurisdiction of the Particular Case

Christie v. Rolscreen

Legislative Facts

Hollinrake v. Law Enforcement Academy

Major Life Activities

Michael Biggles (Lovelady)

Hollinrake v. Law Enforcement Academy



Most Significant Relationship Test for Choice of Law

Christie v. Rolscreen

Nature of the Occupation Defense

Michael Biggles (Lovelady)

Smith v. ADM Feed Corporation

Nonmembers

Diane Humburd

Official Notice

Diane Humburd

Place

Diane Humburd

Public Accommodation

Diane Humburd

Prudential Insurance Company v. Iowa Civil Rights Commission (District Court)

Reasonable Accommodation

Henkel Corporation v. Iowa Civil Rights Commission (District Court)

Special Damages

Diane Humburd

Subject Matter Jurisdiction

Christie v. RoIscreen

Substantial Evidence

General Electric Co. v. Iowa Civil Rights Commission

Hy-Vee Food Stores, Inc. v. Iowa Civil Rights Commission

Landals v. Rolfes

J & J Motors v. Iowa Civil Rights Commission (District Court)

Best Western Holiday Motor Lodge v. Iowa Civil Rights Commission (District Court)

United Parcel Service v. Iowa Civil Rights Commission (District Court)

Henkel Corporation v. Iowa Civil Rights Commission (District Court)

Substantially Handicapped

Michael Biggles (Lovelady)

Fogel v. Trustees of Iowa Colleges

Hollinrake v. Law Enforcement Academy

Annear v. State

Soloman v. State

Henkel Corporation v. Iowa Civil Rights Commission (District Court)

Torts

Diane Humburd



EVIDENCE AND PROOF

Burden of Persuasion

Diane Humburd

Ann M. Redies

Robert E. Swanson

Michael Biggles (Lovelady)

Rachel Helkenn

Hulme v. Barrett

Hy-Vee Food Stores, Inc. v. Iowa Civil Rights Commission

Perkins v. International Union of Operating Engineers

Burden of Production

Diane Humburd

Ann M. Redies

Robert E. Swanson

Michael Biggles (Lovelady)

Rachel Helkenn

Hulme v. Barrett

Hy-Vee Food Stores, Inc. v. Iowa Civil Rights Commission

Landals v. Rolfes

Perkins v. International Union of Operating Engineers

Circumstantial Evidence

Ann M. Redies

Rachel Helkenn

Landals v. Rolfes

Credibility of Witnesses

Diane Humburd

Ann M. Redies

Robert E. Swanson

Michael Biggles (Lovelady)

Rachel Helkenn

Keokuk Steel Casting v. Iowa Civil Rights Commission (District Court)

Direct Evidence

Diane Humburd

Ann M. Redies

Robert E. Swanson

Michael Biggles (Lovelady)

Rachel Helkenn

Landals v. Rolfes

Exclusion of Evidence

Hulme v. Barrett

Judicial Notice

Diane Humburd

Labor Market-Workforce Comparisons

Hy-Vee Food Stores, Inc. v. Iowa Civil Rights Commission

Official Notice

Diane Humburd

Order and Allocation of Proof: Disparate Impact

Hy-Vee Food Stores, Inc. v. Iowa Civil Rights Commission

Perkins v. International Union of Operating Engineers

Prudential Insurance Company v. Iowa Civil Rights Commission (District Court)

Order and Allocation of Proof: Disparate Treatment: Circumstantial Evidence "Pretext" Cases

Ann M. Redies

Rachel Helkenn

Hy-Vee Food Stores, Inc. v. Iowa Civil Rights Commission

Annear v. State

Landals v. Rolfes

Smith v. ADM Feed Corporation

Perkins v. International Union of Operating Engineers

J & J Motors v. Iowa Civil Rights Commission (District Court)

Keokuk Steel Casting v. Iowa Civil Rights Commission (District Court)

United Parcel Service v. Iowa Civil Rights Commission (District Court)

Order and Allocation of Proof: Disparate Treatment: Direct Evidence Cases

Diane Humburd

Ann M. Redies

Robert E. Swanson

Michael Biggles (Lovelady)

Rachel Helkenn

Landals v. Rolfes

Order and Allocation of Proof: Disparate Treatment: Mixed Motives

Ann M. Redies

Hulme v. Barrett

Hy-Vee Food Stores, Inc. v. Iowa Civil Rights Commission

Landals v. Rolfes

Order and Allocation of Proof: Failure to Accommodate

Henkel Corporation v. Iowa Civil Rights Commission (District Court)

Order and Allocation of Proof: Hostile Work Environment Cases

Lynch v. City of Des Moines

Preservation of Evidence

United Parcel Service v. Iowa Civil Rights Commission (District Court)

Proof of Age Discrimination

Robert E. Swanson

Rachel Helkenn

Hulme v. Barrett

Landals v. Rolfes

J & J Motors v. Iowa Civil Rights Commission (District Court)

Proof of Attorney Fees

Diane Humburd (Supplemental Decision)

Landals v. Rolfes

Proof of Back Pay

Diane Humburd

Ann M. Redies

Robert E. Swanson

Michael Biggles (Lovelady)

Rachel Helkenn

Hy-Vee Food Stores, Inc. v. Iowa Civil Rights Commission

Landals v. Rolfes

Hy-Vee Food Stores, Inc. v. Iowa Civil Rights Commission (District Court)

Proof of Business Necessity

Michael Biggles (Lovelady)

Hy-Vee Food Stores, Inc. v. Iowa Civil Rights Commission

Proof of Constructive Discharge

Ann M. Redies

Proof of a Continuing Violation

Hoa Thi Blood

Hy-Vee Food Stores, Inc. v. Iowa Civil Rights Commission

Lynch v. City of Des Moines

Perkins v. International Union of Operating Engineers

J & J Motors v. Iowa Civil Rights Commission (District Court)

Hy-Vee Food Stores, Inc. v. Iowa Civil Rights Commission (District Court)

Proof of Disability Discrimination

Michael Biggles (Lovelady)

Fogel v. Trustees of Iowa College

Hollinrake v. Iowa Law Enforcement Academy

Annear v. State

Smith v. ADM Feed

Soloman v. State

Brown v. Clark-Peterson Company, Inc. (District Court)

Henkel Corporation v. Iowa Civil Rights Commission (District Court)

Proof of Discriminatory or Retaliatory Discharge

Ann M. Redies

Rachel Helkenn

Hulme v. Barrett

Proof of Disparate Impact

Hy-Vee Food Stores, Inc. v. Iowa Civil Rights Commission

Prudential Insurance Company v. Iowa Civil Rights Commission (District Court)

Proof of Disparate Treatment

Diane Humburd

Ann M. Redies

Robert E. Swanson

Michael Biggles (Lovelady)

Rachel Helkenn

Hy-Vee Food Stores, Inc. v. Iowa Civil Rights Commission

Annear v. State

Landals v. Rolfes

Smith v. ADM Feed Corporation

Perkins v. International Union of Operating Engineers

J & J Motors v. Iowa Civil Rights Commission (District Court)

Proof of Emotional Distress

Diane Humburd

Ann M. Redies

Robert E. Swanson

Rachel Helkenn

Hy-Vee Food Stores, Inc. v. Iowa Civil Rights Commission

Lynch v. City of Des Moines

United Parcel Service v. Iowa Civil Rights Commission (District Court)

Proof of Failure to Accommodate

Annear v. State Smith v. ADM Feed Corporation

Proof of Failure to Hire\Promote

Ann M. Redies

Robert E. Swanson

Michael Biggles (Lovelady)

Hy-Vee Food Stores, Inc. v. Iowa Civil Rights Commission

Proof of Failure to Mitigate Damages

Diane Humburd

Robert E. Swanson

Michael Biggles (Lovelady)

Rachel Helkenn

Keokuk Steel Casting v. Iowa Civil Rights Commission (District Court)

Best Western Holiday Motor Lodge v. Iowa Civil Rights Commission (District Court)

United Parcel Service v. Iowa Civil Rights Commission (District Court)

Prudential Insurance Company v. Iowa Civil Rights Commission (District Court)

Proof of Failure to Provide Child Care Services

Diane Humburd

Proof of Pay or Wage Discrimination

Ann M. Redies

Proof of Protected Class Status

Rachel Helkenn

Hulme v. Barrett

Proof of Retaliation

Robert E. Swanson

Hulme v. Barrett

Vislisel v. Iowa Civil Rights Commission

Polk County Secondary Roads v. Iowa Civil Rights Commission (District Court)

Keokuk Steel Casting v. Iowa Civil Rights Commission (District Court)

Proof of Sexual Harassment

Lynch v. City of Des Moines

Statistical Proof

Hy-Vee Food Stores, Inc. v. Iowa Civil Rights Commission

Prudential Insurance Company v. Iowa Civil Rights Commission (District Court)

Subjective Criteria

Hy-Vee Food Stores, Inc. v. Iowa Civil Rights Commission

Substantial Evidence

General Electric Co. v. Iowa Civil Rights Commission

Hy-Vee Food Stores, Inc. v. Iowa Civil Rights Commission

J & J Motors v. Iowa Civil Rights Commission (District Court)

Best Western Holiday Motor Lodge v. Iowa Civil Rights Commission (District Court)

United Parcel Service v. Iowa Civil Rights Commission (District Court)

Henkel Corporation v. Iowa Civil Rights Commission (District Court)



JUDICIAL REVIEW

Abuse of Discretion

Perkins v. International Union of Operating Engineers

Administrative Rules

Hollinrake v. Law Enforcement Academy

Arbitrary and Capricious

Vislisel v. Iowa Civil Rights Commission

Perkins v. International Union of Operating Engineers

Exclusivity of 17A.19 Judicial Review Procedures

Lynch v. City of Des Moines

Law of the Case

Annear v. State

Motion to Dismiss

Hollinrake v. Law Enforcement Academy

No Probable Cause Finding

Vislisel v. Iowa Civil Rights Commission

Perkins v. International Union of Operating Engineers

Preservation of Error

Hy-Vee Food Stores, Inc. v. Iowa Civil Rights Commission

Standard of Review/ Scope of Review

Fogel v. Trustees of Iowa Colleges

General Electric Co. v. Iowa Civil Rights Commission

Hulme v. Barrett

Hy-Vee Food Stores, Inc. v. Iowa Civil Rights Commission

Landals v. Rolfes

Lynch v. City of Des Moines

Smith v. ADM Feed Corporation

General Electric Co. v. Iowa Civil Rights Commission

Vislisel v. Iowa Civil Rights Commission

Perkins v. International Union of Operating Engineers

J & J Motors v. Iowa Civil Rights Commission (District Court)

Keokuk Steel Casting v. Iowa Civil Rights Commission (District Court)

Best Western Holiday Motor Lodge v. Iowa Civil Rights Commission (District Court)

United Parcel Service v. Iowa Civil Rights Commission(District Court)

Prudential Insurance Company v. Iowa Civil Rights Commission (District Court)

Henkel Corporation v. Iowa Civil Rights Commission (District Court)

Substantial Evidence

General Electric Co. v. Iowa Civil Rights Commission

Hy-Vee Food Stores, Inc. v. Iowa Civil Rights Commission

Keokuk Steel Casting v. Iowa Civil Rights Commission (District Court)

Best Western Holiday Motor Lodge v. Iowa Civil Rights Commission (District Court)

United Parcel Service v. Iowa Civil Rights Commission (District Court)

Henkel Corporation v. Iowa Civil Rights Commission (District Court)

 

PROCEDURE AND JURISDICTION

Administrative Release to Sue

Hulme v. Barrett

Amendment of Complaint

Hoa Thi Blood

Robert E. Swanson

Amendment of Pleading

Annear v. State

Lynch v. City of Des Moines

Claims Not Alleged in Complaint

Robert E. Swanson

Hulme v. Barrett

Lynch v. City of Des Moines

Continuing Violation

Hoa Thi Blood

Hy-Vee Food Stores, Inc. v. Iowa Civil Rights Commission

Lynch v. City of Des Moines

Perkins v. International Union of Operating Engineers

J & J Motors v. Iowa Civil Rights Commission (District Court)

Hy-Vee Food Stores, Inc. v. Iowa Civil Rights Commission (District Court)

Default Judgment

Diane Humburd

Discovery

Diane Humburd

Jurisdiction of the Particular Case

Christie v. RoIscreen

Hulme v. Barrett

Lynch v. City of Des Moines

Jury Trial of Claim Under the Iowa Civil Rights Act

Smith v. ADM Feed Corporation

Law of the Case

Annear v. State

Motion to Dismiss

Robert Swanson

Stephanie Juehring

Rachel Helkenn

Annear v. State

Participation of Investigating Commissioner

United Parcel Service v. Iowa Civil Rights Commission (District Court)

Personal Jurisdiction

Diane Humburd

Preemption

Hulme v. Barrett

Primary Jurisdiction of Commission Over 601 A Violations

Polk County Secondary Roads v. Iowa Civil Rights Commission (District Court)

Prudential Insurance Company v. Iowa Civil Rights Commission (District Court)

Retained Jurisdiction

Diane Humburd

Diane Humburd (Supplemental Decision)

Ann M. Redies

Landals v. Rolfes

Subject Matter Jurisdiction

Diane Humburd

Christie v. Rolscreen

Hulme v. Barrett

Lynch v. City of Des Moines

Prudential Insurance Company v. Iowa Civil Rights Commission (District Court)

Summary Judgment

Fogel v. Trustees of Iowa Colleges

Venue

Christie v. Rolscreen

Withdrawal of Complaint

Stephanie Juehring

 

 

REMEDIES

Actual Damages

Robert E. Swanson

Landals v. Rolfes

Advertising Requirements

Robert E. Swanson

Michael Biggles (Lovelady)

Rachel Helkenn

Attorneys Fees

Diane Humburd

Diane Humburd (Supplemental Decision)

Ann M. Redies

Landals v. Rolfes

Back Pay

Diane Humburd

Ann M. Redies

Robert E. Swanson

Michael Biggles (Lovelady)

Rachel Helkenn

Hy-Vee Food Stores, Inc. v. Iowa Civil Rights Commission

Landals v. Rolfes

Hy-Vee Food Stores, Inc. v. Iowa Civil Rights Commission (District Court)

Cease and Desist Order

Robert E. Swanson

Michael Biggles (Lovelady)

Rachel Helkenn

Consequential Damages

Diane Humburd

Costs

Landals v. Rolfes

Deposition Expenses

Landals v. Rolfes

Educational Programs

Rachel Helkenn

Lynch v. City of Des Moines

Emotional Distress Damages

Diane Humburd

Ann M. Redies

Robert E. Swanson

Rachel Helkenn

Hy-Vee Food Stores, Inc. v. Iowa Civil Rights Commission

Lynch v. City of Des Moines

United Parcel Service v. Iowa Civil Rights Commission (District Court)

Expert Witness Fees

Landals v. Rolfes

Failure to Mitigate

Diane Humburd

Robert E. Swanson

Michael Biggles (Lovelady)

Rachel Helkenn

Landals v. Rolfes

Keokuk Steel Casting v. Iowa Civil Rights Commission (District Court)

Best Western Holiday Motor Lodge v. Iowa Civil Rights Commission (District Court)

United Parcel Service v. Iowa Civil Rights Commission (District Court)

United Parcel Service v. Iowa Civil Rights Commission (District Court)

Prudential Insurance Company v. Iowa Civil Rights Commission (District Court)

In General

Diane Humburd

Michael Biggles (Lovelady)

Rachel Helkenn

Lynch v. City of Des Moines

Interest

Diane Humburd

Ann M. Redies

Robert E. Swanson

Michael Biggles (Lovelady)

Rachel Helkenn

Landals v. Rolfes

Fishercrest Apartments v. Iowa Civil Rights Commission (District Court)

Interim Earnings

Diane Humburd

Ann M. Redies

Robert E. Swanson

Michael Biggles (Lovelady)

Rachel Helkenn

Litigation Expenses

Landals v. Rolfes

Notification of Past Applicants

Michael Biggles (Lovelady)

Posting of Notices

Ann M. Redies

Robert E. Swanson

Michael Biggles (Lovelady)

Press Release

Michael Biggles (Lovelady)

Punitive Damages

Keokuk Steel Casting v. Iowa Civil Rights Commission (District Court)

Reporting Requirements

Ann M. Redies

Robert E. Swanson

Michael Biggles (Lovelady)

Rachel Helkenn

Special Damages

Diane Humburd

Written Policies

Ann M. Redies

Robert E. Swanson

 

STATUTORY CONSTRUCTION

Diane Humburd

Hoa Thi Blood

Hulme v. Barrett

Hy-Vee Food Stores, Inc. v. Iowa Civil Rights Commission

Hollinrake v. Law Enforcement Academy

Prudential Insurance Company v. Iowa Civil Rights Commission (District Court)



THEORIES OF DISCRIMINATION (Agency Contested Case Decisions Only)

Disparate Treatment

Diane Humburd

Ann M. Redies

Robert E. Swanson

Michael Biggles (Lovelady)

Rachel Helkenn